Old Comrades
Copyright© 2026 by Agnes Giberne
Chapter 14: Dorothea’s Letter
“I HAVE been very nearly a year at home now,” wrote Dorothea Tracy to her friend, Mrs. Kirkpatrick, one dull December afternoon.
“Nearly a whole year! What a long time a year is! I feel ages older than when I saw you last. Quite middle-aged and experienced.”
“It has not been an unhappy year. Need one ever be unhappy, I wonder, merely because things are not exactly as one would choose? Or rather, —no, I don’t wonder, because I am perfectly sure one need not.”
“I want to tell you that I really have tried hard to follow the advice you gave me that last evening, —you will remember it, though perhaps not as clearly as I do. Trying to do doesn’t always mean doing; but indeed I have tried.”
“You said that I must always live steadily by rule, not let myself be a victim to impulses; and above all, that I was not to be indulgent to self in little matters, because that always means self-indulgence in greater matters too. And I was always to hold myself ready to do whatever might come to hand, and yet not to be discontented if very little came to hand. So you see I have not forgotten.”
“It was a hard battle at first not to be discontented. Everything was so different from what I had fancied beforehand. And for a time there seemed really nothing to do, except to run up or down stairs for my father, and to be kind to little Minnie. But one thing after another turned up; and I have found, as you said I should, that one always may be busy and useful, if only one will.”
“As for self-discipline, I shouldn’t think one ever need be in any difficulty.”
“At first, of course, I was in the swing of school habits; and I kept on doing as you had taught me, half in a mechanical way. But there came a time when I began to realise that I was free to please myself in little things, and that there was nobody to control me, and somehow I began to give in.”
“I wonder whether you ever did that, and found out how dreadfully self-indulgent one can grow in a very little while.”
“I didn’t see it at all at first. The change wasn’t slow, but it was so gliding. I never had an idea before how easily one can slip and slide into a sort of small slavery to one’s body, if once one relaxes guard! You won’t believe it, perhaps, but I was getting quite lazy—always lounging about in easy-chairs, and lying in bed too late in the morning, and indulging myself in story reading when I ought to have been doing some other thing, and fancying myself tired when I only wanted rousing, and even getting fanciful and fussy about food—which you know was an old trouble, but I really did think I had quite got over it.”
“My father got vexed one morning, when I was down rather late for breakfast, and he told me I was indolent. That helped me to see, first. And then Lent came; and on the first Sunday evening we had a sermon from Mr. Mordan, on ‘bringing the body into subjection,’ and ‘using such abstinence,’—in the Collect, you know.”
“He did speak plainly! He warned us to take care of just those very things that I had been growing careless about. He mentioned a good many ways in which one might fail; and amongst them were too much lying in bed, and daintiness in eating, and self-indulgence in reading. And he advised us to make particular use of Lent by going right in the face of any habits that were getting a mastery over us—for yielding in one thing would be yielding in all, and every time one is beaten, one gets weaker. ‘But mind,’ he said, ‘you must not think that when Lent is over, you are free to revert to your bad habits.’ That did so remind me of you, and how you used to say, ‘Don’t slacken because Lent is ended.’”
“It was a hard fight after that, but I did begin to get up earlier, and not to let myself lounge about or read stories in the morning, and to make myself sometimes eat things I didn’t like. After a while it grew easier; and then I felt how much I had owed to you. But somehow I never felt inclined to write this all until now.”
“Soon after I came home, my father subscribed to a library near for me, and that has been a great delight. Mr. and Mrs. Mordan lend me books too, now and then. I make it a rule to have some volume of solid reading always in hand, and a good sensible story besides for the evening—not a trashy sort.”
“And only think! My father goes to Church with me now, at least once every Sunday. Isn’t that a change? I could so seldom persuade him at first.”
“One thing has disappointed me. For a time he was so much brighter and more chatty. He used to tell stories of his Army life, and he really seemed to like me to chat to him. But that is over now. He has been getting more and more silent through the autumn—even gloomy. Some days, he hardly speaks at all, and when he does, he speaks sharply. I feel almost sure that some trouble or worry is weighing on his mind; and I have an idea that it has to do with money.”
“I don’t think it can be wrong of me to say all this to you, because you have always been—”
Dorothea came to a pause, and sat, pen in hand, considering.
“Am I wrong?” she murmured. “Ought I to say so much? Mrs. Kirkpatrick is my oldest and dearest friend—but she is not my father’s friend. He calls her ‘an estimable old lady’—and that is all. Is it quite honourable of me to tell her about his affairs? He would not tell her himself. Have I the right, without his leave?”
She sat thoughtfully, gazing towards the lighted candle.
“Perhaps he is waiting till he is sure that I am trustworthy, and not a gossip, before he speaks out. After all, his affairs are not the concern of other people—not even of my dear Mrs. Kirkpatrick. If I were at a loss to know what to do, perhaps my right plan would be to go to Mr. Mordan for advice, but I don’t see that advice would help me just now. I have no right to press for my father’s secrets; and unless he speaks to me himself, I cannot do anything.”
Another break. Dorothea ran her eyes through the letter.
“What a lot I have written about myself. It is I—I—I all through! How horrid! I don’t think I will send it off to-day. Perhaps I will re-write part to-morrow. That is the worst of living so much alone. One gets into such a narrow circle of ideas, and self grows so important. To be sure Mrs. Kirkpatrick begs to be told everything, but still—No, I’ll wait.”
Dorothea put pen and paper away, and peeped through the venetian into the lamp-lit street.
“Why doesn’t my father come in? He is not often so late. However, there is not enough fog to hinder anybody; so I dare say he has some good reason.”
She had hardly settled down to her book before the door was whisked open.
“Beg pardon, Miss; I thought your Pa was at home,” Mrs. Stirring exclaimed. “Mr. Claughton wants to see the Colonel.”
“My father will be in directly,” said Dorothea; while, “Which Mr. Claughton?” flashed through her mind.
One candle does not make a room light, and for a moment she was in uncertainty; but before the newcomer’s features were discernible, she knew his walk. “How do you do? I am expecting my father every moment,” she said. “Will you sit down? He cannot be long now.”
“Thanks.” And Edred took a seat.
He looked pale, Dorothea thought, and his air was alike preoccupied and depressed.
“We have not seen you for a long while. Hardly since the summer.”
“No; I have been remiss, I know. There has been so much to do, especially since my holiday.”
“You were away all October, were you not? But you don’t seem much the better for your month’s rest,” said Dorothea, suddenly conscious that her old shyness of Edred existed no longer. She could hardly have told why. He had perhaps never been less cordial in manner; yet she had never felt less afraid of him. It occurred to her mind that here was an opportunity to find out more about the Erskines of Craye—about Dolly, in particular. Why not? If she could ask questions of Mervyn, what should keep her from putting queries to Edred?
“And I will,” she told herself smilingly, “if my father leaves me time.”
“There is nothing wrong with me,” came stiffly in answer; and then, as if the word were extorted by conscience, —”Except—”
“Except that you have rather too much to do, I suppose.”
“Thanks, no; not in the least.”
“Did you spend your month at home?”
“Three days of it. The rest in Scotland. No, I have not been home since.”
“That was a very scanty allowance for your sister.”
“My sister went to Scotland with me.”
“Ah, Scotland is delightful. But I know Scotland, and I don’t know Craye. I am more interested in Craye,” said Dorothea. “You know I have seen your sister once, and your brother more than once. He is so like you.”
“Mervyn! We are opposites.”
“In character, are you? But not in face.”
The frank simplicity of Dorothea’s manner was taking effect. Mr. Claughton glanced up with more of attention than he had vouchsafed hitherto.
“Likeness is surely a matter of expression, at least, as much as of feature. However, one cannot be a judge of oneself.”
“I don’t think you are alike in expression; but nobody could help seeing that you are brothers.”
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.